Fast answer: simple return on investment (ROI) = (ending value − starting value + income received) / starting value. To compare investments held for different lengths of time, convert to an annualized return, also called the compound annual growth rate (CAGR): (ending value / starting value)1/years − 1. An investment that grows from $10,000 to $16,000 in 5 years has a 60% total return but a CAGR of 9.86% per year. Subtract fees and inflation to see what you really earned.
Investment statements, fund fact sheets and advertisements all quote returns differently. Knowing how to calculate return yourself lets you compare options fairly, check what your portfolio is actually doing, and set realistic expectations for future savings. For projections, try our investment calculator.
Simple return (ROI)
The simplest measure answers: by what percentage did my money grow?
ROI = (ending value − starting value + income) / starting value × 100
Example 1
You buy $5,000 of an exchange-traded fund. One year later it is worth $5,350 and has paid $100 in distributions.
- Price gain: $350
- Income: $100
- ROI: (350 + 100) / 5,000 = 9.0%
Including distributions or dividends gives the total return. Looking at price change alone (7% here) understates what you earned.
Why annualizing matters
A 30% return sounds better than a 12% return, until you learn that the 30% took four years and the 12% took one. To compare fairly, express returns per year. Simply dividing by the number of years is wrong because it ignores compounding.
The CAGR formula
CAGR = (ending value / starting value)1 / years − 1
Example 2
$10,000 grows to $16,000 in 5 years.
- Ending / starting: 16,000 / 10,000 = 1.6
- 1.6 raised to the power 1/5 (0.2): 1.0986
- CAGR: 1.0986 − 1 = 9.86% per year
Dividing 60% by 5 years gives 12%, which overstates the true annual growth. If you invested $10,000 at 12% compounded for 5 years, you would end up with $17,623, not $16,000.
Calculating CAGR in a spreadsheet
Use =(B2/A2)^(1/C2)-1, where A2 is the starting value, B2 the ending value and C2 the number of years. For periods that are not whole years, use the exact number of days divided by 365.
Returns with deposits and withdrawals
Real portfolios rarely sit untouched. If you add money along the way, the simple formula breaks because some of the growth is just your own deposits. Two measures handle this.
Time-weighted return
Time-weighted return measures how the investments themselves performed, removing the effect of when money was added or withdrawn. You calculate the return for each period between cash flows and multiply them together: (1 + r1) × (1 + r2) × … − 1. Fund managers report time-weighted returns because they do not control when investors add money.
Money-weighted return
Money-weighted return (internal rate of return) measures your personal experience, including the timing of your deposits. If you invested a large amount just before a strong year, your money-weighted return will be higher than the fund’s time-weighted return. Many Canadian brokerages now show a personal rate of return on statements, which is typically money-weighted.
Example 3: why the two can differ
You invest $1,000. In year 1 the fund rises 20% to $1,200. You then add $5,000, bringing the total to $6,200. In year 2 the fund falls 10%, leaving $5,580.
- Time-weighted return: 1.20 × 0.90 − 1 = 8% total, about 3.9% per year.
- Your money-weighted experience is negative: you contributed $6,000 and ended with $5,580, because most of your money was invested during the losing year.
Neither measure is wrong; they answer different questions.
The impact of fees
Fees reduce returns every year, and the effect compounds. Mutual funds and ETFs disclose a management expense ratio (MER), which is deducted from the fund’s assets before returns are reported to you.
Example 4: MER over 25 years
You invest $50,000 for 25 years. The underlying investments earn 6% a year before fees.
- With a 2.00% MER, net return 4%: $50,000 × 1.0425 = $133,292
- With a 0.25% MER, net return 5.75%: $50,000 × 1.057525 = $202,292
The difference is about $69,000 on the same investments, purely because of fees. These are illustrations with a constant assumed return; actual returns vary. Our compound interest calculator lets you test different rates.
Real return after inflation
A nominal return tells you how many more dollars you have. A real return tells you how much more you can buy.
Real return = (1 + nominal return) / (1 + inflation) − 1
With a 7% nominal return and 2.5% inflation: 1.07 / 1.025 − 1 = 4.39%. Subtracting inflation directly (4.5%) is a close approximation for low numbers. For long-term planning, working in real returns keeps projections in today’s dollars, which are easier to understand.
After-tax return
In a non-registered account, investment income is taxed differently depending on its type: interest is fully taxable, eligible Canadian dividends receive a dividend tax credit, and only half of a capital gain has typically been included in income. In a TFSA, returns are tax-free; in an RRSP, tax is deferred until withdrawal. When comparing a GIC paying interest with a dividend-paying stock in a taxable account, compare after-tax returns. Our RRSP vs TFSA calculator shows how account type changes the outcome.
Benchmarking your return
A return means little without a comparison. A Canadian equity fund that earned 8% in a year when the broad Canadian market earned 12% underperformed, even though 8% sounds good. Compare each investment with an appropriate benchmark index of similar risk and composition, using the same period and including dividends.
Common mistakes
- Ignoring dividends and distributions. Total return includes income.
- Averaging annual returns. +50% then −50% averages 0%, but $100 becomes $75. Use CAGR.
- Counting deposits as gains. New contributions are not returns.
- Forgetting fees and taxes. Net return is what you keep.
- Short-period bias. One great year does not predict the next. Look at longer periods.
- Confusing nominal and real. Long-term goals should be planned in real terms.
Quick reference
- Simple ROI: (end − start + income) / start
- CAGR: (end / start)1/years − 1
- Real return: (1 + nominal) / (1 + inflation) − 1
- After-tax return on interest: rate × (1 − marginal tax rate)
- Future value: start × (1 + return)years
Worked example: measuring a real portfolio over three years
Theory becomes clearer with one complete example. Nadia opened a non-registered account three years ago with $20,000 and made no further deposits. Here is what happened:
- Year 1: the portfolio rose to $22,400 and paid $400 of dividends, which she reinvested.
- Year 2: it fell to $21,300, with $420 of dividends reinvested.
- Year 3: it rose to $24,800, with $450 of dividends reinvested.
Because the dividends were reinvested, they are already included in the year-end values. Her total return over three years is (24,800 − 20,000) / 20,000 = 24%. Her CAGR is (24,800 / 20,000)1/3 − 1 = 1.240.3333 − 1 = 7.43% per year.
Her year-by-year returns were: year 1, 24,800 is not used yet; 22,400 / 20,000 − 1 = 12.0%; year 2, 21,300 / 22,400 − 1 = −4.9%; year 3, 24,800 / 21,300 − 1 = 16.4%. The simple average of these three numbers is 7.83%, which overstates her real annual growth of 7.43%. The gap between the arithmetic average and the CAGR grows larger the more volatile the returns are, which is why the CAGR is the honest number to report.
If inflation averaged 2.5% over the period (illustrative), her real CAGR is 1.0743 / 1.025 − 1 = 4.8% per year. And since the account is non-registered, she also owed tax each year on the dividends, so her after-tax return is somewhat lower again.
Comparing investments with different risk
Return is only half of the picture. Two investments with the same 6% CAGR can feel very different if one moved steadily and the other swung between gains of 25% and losses of 20%. Volatility matters because it changes the path, and a large drop near the moment you need the money can force you to sell at a loss. A simple way to compare is to look at the worst calendar year and the largest peak-to-trough drop alongside the annualized return. If you would not be comfortable living through the worst year again, the investment may be too risky for your situation, regardless of its average return.
Projecting future value from a return assumption
Once you have a reasonable return assumption, future value is straightforward: future value = present value × (1 + annual return)years. With regular contributions, add the future value of the contributions: payment × ((1 + r)n − 1) / r. For example, $300 a month for 20 years at a 5% annual return (about 0.407% per month) grows to roughly $123,000, of which $72,000 is contributions and the rest is growth. Using a conservative real return, rather than an optimistic nominal one, keeps such projections realistic. Our retirement savings guide shows how to turn these projections into a target.
Frequently asked questions
What is a good annual return?
It depends on risk. Savings accounts and GICs offer low, predictable returns; diversified stock portfolios have historically offered higher long-term returns with significant year-to-year swings. Compare each investment with a benchmark of similar risk.
What is the difference between ROI and CAGR?
ROI is the total percentage gain over the whole period. CAGR converts that gain into a smooth yearly rate, making investments with different holding periods comparable.
Should I include dividends in my return?
Yes. Total return includes price changes and all income received, whether paid out or reinvested.
Why is my personal return different from the fund’s return?
Funds report time-weighted returns, while your personal return depends on when you added or withdrew money.
How do fees affect long-term returns?
Fees are deducted every year and compound over time. A difference of a percentage point or two in annual fees can change a 25-year outcome by tens of thousands of dollars.
This article provides general information only and is not investment advice. Past returns do not guarantee future results; consider speaking with a qualified advisor.

Leave a Reply