Should you keep renting or buy a home? In Canada, the question usually turns into an emotional debate about “throwing money away on rent.” The math is more nuanced. Both renters and owners pay costs they never get back, and the right answer depends on your local prices, your interest rate, how long you will stay and what you would do with the money you do not put into a house. This guide shows you how to run the rent vs buy calculation yourself, step by step, with Canadian rules and a worked example.
Key takeaways
- Compare unrecoverable costs, not rent against a full mortgage payment. Rent is unrecoverable; for owners, the mortgage principal is savings, but interest, property tax, maintenance and the opportunity cost of the down payment are not.
- A popular rule of thumb, the “5% rule,” estimates an owner’s yearly unrecoverable costs at about 5% of the home’s value.
- In Canada, the minimum down payment is 5% on the first $500,000 and 10% on the portion between $500,000 and $1.5 million; homes at $1.5 million or more need 20%.
- With less than 20% down, mortgage loan insurance is mandatory, and its premium (2.80% to 4.00% of the loan for most buyers) changes the math.
- Buying generally makes more sense the longer you stay, because one-time purchase and selling costs are spread over more years.
- Test your own numbers with our rent vs buy calculator.
Why “rent is throwing money away” is the wrong comparison
When you rent, your full rent is a cost. When you own, your monthly mortgage payment is made of two parts: interest, which is a cost, and principal, which reduces your debt and builds equity. Comparing a $2,200 rent with a $2,600 mortgage payment therefore mixes a pure cost with a payment that is partly savings.
But owning also has costs that renters do not see on a monthly bill: property tax, maintenance and repairs, condo fees in many cases, home insurance that is more expensive than tenant insurance, and the investment return you give up on your down payment. A fair comparison puts the renter’s unrecoverable cost (rent plus tenant insurance) next to the owner’s unrecoverable costs.
Step 1: Know the Canadian down payment rules
Before you can estimate ownership costs, you need to know how much cash the purchase requires. The federal rules, updated for mortgage insurance applications submitted on or after December 15, 2024, are summarized by the Department of Finance Canada:
| Purchase price | Minimum down payment |
|---|---|
| Up to $500,000 | 5% of the price |
| $500,000 to $1,499,999 | 5% of the first $500,000 + 10% of the portion above $500,000 |
| $1,500,000 or more | 20% of the price (insured mortgages not available) |
Examples: a $500,000 home requires at least $25,000 down. An $800,000 home requires $25,000 + $30,000 = $55,000. A $1,200,000 home requires $25,000 + $70,000 = $95,000.
The same reform made 30-year amortizations available on insured mortgages for first-time buyers and for buyers of newly built homes. A longer amortization lowers the monthly payment but increases the total interest paid.
Step 2: Add mortgage loan insurance if you put down less than 20%
If your down payment is under 20%, your lender requires mortgage loan insurance. The premium is a percentage of the loan and is usually added to the mortgage. According to CMHC, the premiums on the total loan are:
| Loan-to-value ratio | Down payment | Premium on total loan |
|---|---|---|
| Up to 65% | 35% or more | 0.60% |
| 65.01% to 75% | 25% to 34.99% | 1.70% |
| 75.01% to 80% | 20% to 24.99% | 2.40% |
| 80.01% to 85% | 15% to 19.99% | 2.80% |
| 85.01% to 90% | 10% to 14.99% | 3.10% |
| 90.01% to 95% | 5% to 9.99% | 4.00% |
In Ontario, Quebec and Saskatchewan, provincial sales tax applies to the premium and cannot be added to the loan, so it is an extra cash cost at closing.
Step 3: Estimate the owner’s unrecoverable costs
Owners face three main categories of costs they never get back:
- Mortgage interest. In the early years of a 25-year mortgage, most of each payment is interest. Our mortgage calculator shows the split between interest and principal.
- Property tax, maintenance and insurance. Property tax depends on your municipality. Maintenance varies with the age and type of home; many planners budget around 1% of the home value per year as a starting assumption.
- Opportunity cost of your equity. The money tied up in your down payment could have been invested. Whatever return you assume on that money is a real cost of owning.
On top of these recurring costs, buying and selling come with one-time transaction costs: land transfer tax (welcome tax in Quebec), legal fees, inspection, moving and, when you sell, real estate commissions. These are why short ownership periods are usually expensive.
The 5% rule of thumb
To simplify, some Canadian financial planners use the “5% rule”: an owner’s unrecoverable costs equal roughly 5% of the home’s value per year, made of about 1% property tax, 1% maintenance and 3% cost of capital (a blend of mortgage interest and the return given up on the equity). Divide the result by 12 and compare it to the rent for a similar home.
It is a rough shortcut, not an official rule. If your property tax rate, mortgage rate or expected investment return is very different, replace each component with your own numbers.
Step 4: Run the comparison (worked example)
Let’s take a $500,000 condo in a Canadian city. The same unit rents for $2,200 per month.
The buyer
- Down payment: 10%, or $50,000
- Mortgage before insurance: $450,000
- Insurance premium: 3.10% x $450,000 = $13,950, added to the loan
- Total mortgage: $463,950
- Assumed rate for this illustration: 4.5% fixed, compounded semi-annually, 25-year amortization
- Monthly payment: about $2,568
In the first year, about $20,475 of the payments goes to interest and about $10,339 to principal. So roughly one-third of the payment is savings, not cost.
Applying the 5% rule
5% x $500,000 = $25,000 per year, or about $2,083 per month in unrecoverable costs. Compared with $2,200 of rent, buying and renting are almost equivalent in this example. A small change in the assumptions, such as a higher interest rate, a large special assessment in the condo, or a lower rent, tips the balance.
Summary table
| Item | Renter | Owner |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly housing payment | $2,200 rent | About $2,568 mortgage payment |
| Part that builds wealth | $0 | Principal (about $860/month in year 1) |
| Estimated unrecoverable cost (5% rule) | $2,200 | About $2,083 |
| Cash needed up front | Deposit and moving costs | $50,000 down + closing costs |
| Flexibility to move | High | Lower (selling costs) |
The key insight: the renter only comes out ahead if they actually invest the difference, starting with the $50,000 that would have gone into the down payment, plus any monthly savings. If that money is spent instead, owning usually builds more wealth because mortgage principal acts as forced savings. Our investment calculator helps you estimate what the renter’s portfolio could grow to.
Factors that tip the balance
- How long you will stay. Transaction costs on purchase and sale are fixed; spread over 3 years they hurt, spread over 15 they matter much less.
- Price-to-rent ratio. Divide the home price by one year of rent. In our example: $500,000 / $26,400 is about 19. The higher the ratio, the more renting tends to win on pure numbers.
- Interest rates. Higher rates increase the interest portion of ownership costs. When your term ends, your payment can change; see our guide on mortgage amortization vs mortgage term.
- Tax treatment. Gains on your principal residence are generally not taxed in Canada, which favours owners, while renters can shelter investments in a TFSA or RRSP.
- First-time buyer programs. Tax-advantaged accounts and credits can reduce the cost of buying; read first-time home buyer tax credits in Canada explained.
- Lifestyle. Stability, renovations and pets on one side; flexibility and no repair bills on the other.
How much home can you afford?
Even if buying looks better on paper, lenders will set a ceiling based on your income, debts and the mortgage stress test. Use our mortgage affordability calculator to see your maximum, then plug that price into the rent vs buy calculator. Our guide on how to calculate mortgage payments in Canada explains the payment formula in detail.
Frequently asked questions
Is it cheaper to rent or buy in Canada?
It depends on the city, the property and your assumptions. Compare the rent with an owner’s unrecoverable costs (interest, property tax, maintenance, insurance and opportunity cost), not with the full mortgage payment. In expensive markets where prices are high relative to rents, renting and investing the difference often comes out ahead on paper.
What is the 5% rule for rent vs buy?
It estimates an owner’s yearly unrecoverable costs at about 5% of the home’s value (roughly 1% property tax, 1% maintenance and 3% cost of capital). If you can rent a similar home for less than 5% of its value per year, renting may be financially comparable or better. It is a rule of thumb, not an official standard.
How much down payment do I need to buy a home in Canada?
At least 5% on the first $500,000 and 10% on the portion between $500,000 and $1.5 million. A home priced at $1.5 million or more requires at least 20% down.
How much is CMHC insurance?
For a standard purchase, premiums range from 0.60% to 4.00% of the loan depending on your loan-to-value ratio. With 10% down, the premium is 3.10% of the mortgage. Provincial sales tax applies to the premium in Ontario, Quebec and Saskatchewan.
How long should I plan to stay to make buying worthwhile?
There is no universal number. The shorter the stay, the more one-time costs such as land transfer tax, legal fees and selling commissions weigh on the result. Run your own scenario with different holding periods in the calculator.
Does renting mean I will never build wealth?
No. Renters build wealth if they consistently invest the money they would otherwise have spent on a down payment and higher ownership costs. The challenge is discipline: owning forces savings through principal repayment, while renting relies on you investing the difference.
Conclusion
The rent vs buy decision is not about whether rent is “wasted.” It is about comparing unrecoverable costs on both sides and being honest about what you will do with any money you save. Start with the Canadian down payment and mortgage insurance rules, estimate your ownership costs, apply the 5% rule as a quick check, then refine with your real numbers.
Ready to test your own situation? Open the rent vs buy calculator and compare scenarios side by side.
This article is general information, not financial advice. Rates, rules and premiums can change; confirm details with your lender, CMHC or a qualified financial professional before making a decision.


Leave a Reply